hidden hit counter


HOME

 

FORUM ARCHIVE

 

CAD PLANS

 

TECH FEATURES

 

ADMIN 1

 

ADMIN 2



Top The TRMA Discussion Forum topic #54681
View in linear mode

Subject: "RE: Titanic 3D model project" Previous topic | Next topic
Bill WestWed Apr-19-17 02:27 PM
Member since Feb 02nd 2010
470 posts
Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author Click to view this author's profile Click to add this author to your buddy list
#54980, "RE: Titanic 3D model project"
In response to In response to 71


          

Hi Steve

I think the emergency telegraph was just for a breakdown of the regular one. Nowadays the bridge has remote control of the engines and the backup is the little VHF radio absolutely everybody in the deck and engine depts. has on their belt. If you are still here Morten, are you required to clip it to your pajamas when you are sleeping? LoL

I was waiting for more renderings to see what space was available for guessing the telegraph location. Can you turn the room columns and catwalks back on at this moment to help judge?

A location aft of the reverser is a bit around a corner. I'm guessing either wall mounts on the now crowded engine column or two hanging on each side of the central room column. But that middle room column is actually too far aft and the forward one shows nothing in the Marconigraph/Electrician telephone picture.

Because of the water tight bulkheads the chain route to the engine room likely runs along Scotland road on E deck. How about if from there it dropped straight down the inner walls of the E & F corridors to the shop/stores on G deck and ran directly inward along the ER room I-beam towards the forward ER room column? Just after it passes between the LPA and the HP it is a straight drop for the chain case to the forward side of the HP engine column. The simplicity of such a route and the availability of space just forward of the HP column makes me think this might be the location for our telegraphs. Looking at your last engine rendering I don't see any other available and convenient place and this one is practical to get to.

So how about taking a single sided telegraph and mount it on a pipe projecting from the fore side of the HP column. Add a second head forward for the emergency receiver. Do the same on the other engine and then add the Boiler room telegraph and Kilroy control under the port telegraphs. Cooperas and http://titanic-model.com/articles/tech/TechFeatureAugust2005.htm have pictures of both the single BR telegraph transmitter and the Kilroy transmitter. This puts the all the controls in arm's reach from the reverser to the telegraphs. If you can draw this up I think we will be able to judge whether it is plausible and if it seems a likely guess location for now.

For our other mystery how about if we try hanging a gauge board from the catwalks either above the telephones or over a desk placed between the reversers?

Bill

  

Alert | IP Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

Titanic 3D model project [View all] , SteveFury, Mon Feb-20-17 07:27 PM
  RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Feb 21st 2017, #1
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Feb 21st 2017, #2
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Feb 22nd 2017, #3
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 31st 2017, #119
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Feb 25th 2017, #4
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Feb 25th 2017, #5
RE: Titanic 3D model project, J. Kent Layton, Feb 27th 2017, #6
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 01st 2017, #7
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 01st 2017, #8
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 03rd 2017, #9
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 03rd 2017, #10
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 09th 2017, #11
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 11th 2017, #12
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 12th 2017, #13
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 13th 2017, #14
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 16th 2017, #15
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 17th 2017, #16
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 19th 2017, #17
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 19th 2017, #18
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, Ralph Currell, Mar 23rd 2017, #19
           RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 23rd 2017, #20
                RE: Titanic 3D model project, Ralph Currell, Mar 24th 2017, #21
                     RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 24th 2017, #22
                          RE: Titanic 3D model project, Ralph Currell, Mar 24th 2017, #23
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 25th 2017, #24
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Karol_W, Mar 25th 2017, #25
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 26th 2017, #26
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 27th 2017, #27
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Scott Andrews, Jun 25th 2017, #127
      RE: More regarding WTD at WTB "K", Scott Andrews, Jun 26th 2017, #128
           RE: More regarding WTD at WTB , SteveFury, Jun 28th 2017, #129
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 27th 2017, #28
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 27th 2017, #29
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 28th 2017, #30
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 30th 2017, #31
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 30th 2017, #32
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 30th 2017, #33
           RE: Titanic 3D model project, Karol_W, Mar 30th 2017, #34
                RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 30th 2017, #35
                     RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 30th 2017, #36
                          RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Mar 30th 2017, #37
                               RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 30th 2017, #38
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Mar 31st 2017, #39
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 02nd 2017, #40
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, tucky, Apr 02nd 2017, #41
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 03rd 2017, #42
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 04th 2017, #43
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 04th 2017, #44
RE: Titanic 3D model project, tucky, Apr 04th 2017, #45
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 04th 2017, #46
           RE: Titanic 3D model project, tucky, Apr 04th 2017, #47
                RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 05th 2017, #48
                     RE: Titanic 3D model project, tucky, Apr 05th 2017, #49
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 08th 2017, #50
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Karol_W, Apr 09th 2017, #51
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 09th 2017, #52
           RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 10th 2017, #53
                RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 10th 2017, #55
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 10th 2017, #54
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 11th 2017, #56
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 11th 2017, #57
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, Ralph Currell, Apr 11th 2017, #58
           RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 11th 2017, #59
                RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 11th 2017, #60
                     RE: Titanic 3D model project, Ralph Currell, Apr 11th 2017, #61
                          RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 11th 2017, #62
                               RE: Titanic 3D model project, Ralph Currell, Apr 13th 2017, #63
                                    RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 13th 2017, #64
                                         RE: Titanic 3D model project, Ralph Currell, Apr 13th 2017, #65
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 14th 2017, #66
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Karol_W, Apr 15th 2017, #67
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 15th 2017, #68
           RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 16th 2017, #69
                RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 16th 2017, #70
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 18th 2017, #71
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 19th 2017 #72
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 19th 2017, #73
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 23rd 2017, #74
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 23rd 2017, #75
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 23rd 2017, #76
           RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Apr 24th 2017, #77
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Apr 30th 2017, #78
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 01st 2017, #79
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 01st 2017, #80
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 02nd 2017, #81
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 06th 2017, #82
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 09th 2017, #85
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 07th 2017, #83
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Ralph Currell, May 08th 2017, #84
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 09th 2017, #86
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 10th 2017, #87
           RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 10th 2017, #88
                RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 10th 2017, #89
                     RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 10th 2017, #91
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Scott Andrews, May 10th 2017, #90
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 11th 2017, #92
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 11th 2017, #93
           RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 12th 2017, #94
                RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 12th 2017, #95
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Jul 12th 2017, #130
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 13th 2017, #96
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 14th 2017, #97
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 15th 2017, #98
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 16th 2017, #99
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Ralph Currell, May 16th 2017, #100
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 16th 2017, #101
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 16th 2017, #102
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Ralph Currell, May 16th 2017, #103
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 17th 2017, #104
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 17th 2017, #105
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 18th 2017, #106
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 18th 2017, #107
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 19th 2017, #108
      RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 20th 2017, #109
           RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 20th 2017, #110
                RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 21st 2017, #111
                RE: Titanic 3D model project, Scott Andrews, May 24th 2017, #112
                     RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 24th 2017, #113
                          RE: Titanic 3D model project, William W. Young, May 24th 2017, #114
                          RE: Titanic 3D model project, Scott Andrews, May 28th 2017, #116
                               RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, May 29th 2017, #117
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveHall, May 27th 2017, #115
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, May 30th 2017, #118
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Ralph Currell, Jun 01st 2017, #120
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Jun 01st 2017, #121
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Jun 02nd 2017, #122
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Jun 05th 2017, #123
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Jun 11th 2017, #124
RE: Titanic 3D model project, Bill West, Jun 23rd 2017, #125
RE: Titanic 3D model project, SteveFury, Jun 25th 2017, #126

Top The TRMA Discussion Forum topic #54681 Previous topic | Next topic


Titanic artwork at top of page is owned and copyright of Stuart Williamson and is used with permission.